Well it's over shadowed by other free to play mmorpgs.... You have so many to pick from now..I know graphics are not everything to a game, but it would turn a lot of people away.
Graphics taste is totally subjective ... if graphics are so important, why does Runescape have so many players? For my taste, Eldevin is clearly superior in every way to that one, except perhaps in releasing new content. And new does not always imply good or better anyway.
Can not debate the fact of so many ftp mmorpg's to choose from. But imo Eldevin is one of the best of kind. Eldevin has an especially good social aspect imo. Great community. Developers could do themselves a favor by being more responsive.