40 replies to this topic

[TreeFrog]

This round contestants were asked to create a piece of art with this render: http://i1191.photobu... ... 89f519.png

How the voting works: <-- Different this round!!
You will pick your 2 favorite pieces from the four entries below. Please provide a short reason for each choice along with your vote.

Voting Ends 0:00ST 2/26/2013

Here's the art:

A. < Cassafras


B. < Grimmhawk


C. < Athdenald


D. < aa0007

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

[aa0007]

Wow, amazing pieces guys (Not that I was expecting otherwise ).

Looks like I don't stand a chance .

[TreeFrog]

B.

I like that it actually uses the appropriate Chinese text. And it looks nice!

Please choose 2.

[Jashan]

I like B and D

B because the dragon in the background

D because it reminds me of old school nintendo street fighter

All around nice work by everyone.

[Gatornade]

All very nice pieces there. Hard to narrow it down but I will have to say that I like:

B - Dragon background is neat, like the look of the lettering/words

C - I like the coloring pitch, very pleasant.

[DarkWillie]

WOW! Man, I have been out of the forum for too long... GGT6 and I'm looking at the final four

OK, on to the real reason I'm here...

B. My first choice... love the simple use of the render. The background fits and I love the text. The colors are very eye-catching but not overbearing. Lighting is well placed, good attention to detail.

C. Second choice... very difficult to choose from the other 3, but in the end C gets my vote. Good use of lighting, and I like the way the right foot and fist are sharpened while the left is faded and blurred as to give it a rather 3D appearance.

Good work all, and sorry I missed the other rounds.

[Roan]

B & C get my vote!

A- Love the colors and feeling of it. Altought the C4D on the leg seems random to me and not sure about the insertions of image around it.

B- Smooth, neat, great look! Dragon looks awesome and the text s simply beautiful!

C- Coloring and smudging in BG is great!

D- Nice work here too, C4D lokks good in there! I dislike the big black borders tought, they seem to squish the piece.


Once again, AWESOME entries guys!

[Roan]

Tally!

A- 1
B- 7
C- 4
D- 2

[TreeFrog]

Tally!

A- 1
B- 7
C- 4
D- 2

Thanks, but I would prefer, for the sake of consistency, that either Kay or I keep the tally.

[Sahardy]

B - For above reasons. It has a combination of calming and calamity. Though I don't like the white text stuff and the bigger Asian characters.

D - I find this one has good flow (even when using C4Ds, bleh!) I like the transition from dark to light. I think it would be cooler if the pants melded into the dark and the shirt with the light.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[PeterOwnz]

1. C.
2.B
great work guys!

[Haloartist]

Great pieces everyone!

A - I love the concept, but the there are a couple problems to it. Mainly being there is just to much going on that is pretty noticible. The extra part added to the left side and bottom ruined your flow. And I feel like you could have done a little bit better with the text.

B - I love this piece, the colors are wonderful and the dragon added to back really brings everything in I feel. My only problem with it that I think you should have made the entire signature a little smaller. This is my first vote.

C - I like the overall of the piece but the clashing colors is the main reason why my second vote didn't go here. It seems really sloppy and that everything was kinda thrown together. One thing for sure is the black in the top right corner should have been done away with. One other area I don't like is the (I think 2px) fading border.. Borders can ruin a piece if you're not careful. Out of all the pieces the text is best in this one imo though!

D - Although my vote goes to this piece, I must say I hate the border in this one. But! I love everything else about his piece. The Fx coming off of Lee were done wonderfully (you should have put some in under his leg!) The feel of the picture is so nice I really had to make this my second pick!

So if you didn't catch all that, my votes go to B and D!

Again great work everyone!

[ghetoghost]

A - amazing
B - badass
C - crazyness
D - daaaannng

A and B get my vote though

[athdenald]

How many go through this round Mr frog?

[Kayesha]

Totals:

A - 2
B - 12
C - 6
D - 4

[aa0007]

Totals:

A - 2
B - 12
C - 6
D - 4

Heh, that's funny. B has the same number of votes as literally everyone else ... combined! . Seems like we've already got a definite winner, lol. The others are still pretty close though.