117 replies to this topic

[Zukira]

Welcome to the fifth edition of the Grand Graphics Tournament. Every so often the artists gather together and do a battle royal for top bragging rights and a bit of a prize. Who wins?

Well, that my fellow players is up to you!


Below you'll find the entries. Please take a moment and look them over, vote for those in each set that you find most appealing and give a bit of a reason for your rating.

Votes that do not have a reason will not be counted.
*artists, if you do post votes, they won't be counted if you are part of the competition for the round. Just to keep things fair and all.



Please vote for every grouping.

You are voting upon the theme of Tarot Cards, specifically, the Major Arcana. Artists were refered to http://en.wikipedia....ki/Major_Arcana for a reference for the cards. If you are curious you can check out what the cards are supposed to mean if you think it will assist you in voting, but it is not required.

On behalf of my fellow artists, thank you for taking the time to vote and I hope you enjoy the bounty of art that is being laid before you.

[Zukira]

Below are 7 groups of 3 cards each. Please rate each card in each group on a scale of 1 to 10 with a vote of 10 being 'this blows my mind it is so good' and 1 being 'this is phale'.

Please include a reason with your votes - you only have to give a reason for one per set. It doesn't have to be technical. You can just say I liked this one best, or something along those lines but we all know an artist thrives on feedback so don't hesitate to really say what you think.

Voting ends on July 15, 23:00 server time.

Example:

Group samples

a 6/10 - I like it, it is a decent composition. / Good but could use (insert suggestion)
b 3/10 - I don't care for it. / Needs work
c 9/10 - Would the artist sell it after the competition? /I love it!

or

a 5/10
b 8/10 - I liked this one best of this group
c 2/10

________________________________________________________

Group 1

A Noeni


B Dmr


C darkjkr



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Group 2

A Beastboy95


B KyoTenshi


C Treefrog88


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Group 3

A Chagryn


B stormfury3


C j4ckoliver



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Group 4

A Mini100


B AttorraRu


C Godsblade75


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Group 5

A Assasin240


B Athdenald


C zeder



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Group 6

A LadyPike


B MyCurse


C Wesleysdf


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Group 7

A Grimmhawk


B vincent96


C xD34thx

[Zukira]

Round 1 scores

G1

a 5
b 3
c 1

G2
a 1
b 5
c 3

G3
a 3
b 5
c 1

G4
a 5
b 1
c 3

G5
a 4
b 4
c 1

G6
a 5
b 3
c 1

G7
a 5
b 3
c 1

[stormfury3]

Entries (pending)

my vote goes to the lovers card with tidus...

to the maker - you've improved by a lot, and i love the outcome. it looks great, i've seen other tarot cards, and even some CTCG made in this style. just a couple small touch-up's and it could pass for professionally made imho.

/e oh so that's how the voting is, i'll edit later

[Kayesha]

Just want to make sure this is on my radar.

[AttorraRu]

Entries (pending)

my vote goes to the lovers card with tidus...

to the maker - you've improved by a lot, and i love the outcome. it looks great, i've seen other tarot cards, and even some CTCG made in this style. just a couple small touch-up's and it could pass for professionally made imho.

/e oh so that's how the voting is, i'll edit later

Storm, if you're in the GGT you can't vote!

[stormfury3]

Storm, if you're in the GGT you can't vote!

you sure?

[AttorraRu]

Storm, if you're in the GGT you can't vote!

you sure?

yeap, it's in the first page now.

[xD34thx]

Good Luck everyone

[Zukira]

You can vote as a CNC, I know who all entered so I just won't be adding your 'vote' to the tally.


Unless we have really poor turnout for voting in which case I will just drop the votes from artists for the group that they are in when doing a final total.

[stormfury3]

Storm, if you're in the GGT you can't vote!

you sure?

yeap, it's in the first page now.

whew, i really wasn't looking forward to giving cnc for every entry lol

You can vote as a CNC, I know who all entered so I just won't be adding your 'vote' to the tally.


Unless we have really poor turnout for voting in which case I will just drop the votes from artists for the group that they are in when doing a final total.

nty don't want to cnc them

[MyCurse]

I was thinking we could vote, but the vote won't be counted on the particular group our entry is in. Thoughts?

[stormfury3]

I was thinking we could vote, but the vote won't be counted on the particular group our entry is in. Thoughts?

then my original vote still stands... mine isn't in group 4, and i think that will be the only one i cnc

[xkingx]

Is there a place where we can tell who's is whos. I am pretty curious to see storms.

[Zukira]

I was thinking we could vote, but the vote won't be counted on the particular group our entry is in. Thoughts?

That is basically what will happen to the votes if we don't get a decent turnout from non participants.

[Zukira]

Is there a place where we can tell who's is whos. I am pretty curious to see storms.

Not until after the voting is over.

[xkingx]

Can I post on the fsbox and ask or something. Also is all voting gonna be takin seriousley. Like can i just 1/10 everyone.

[stormfury3]

Is there a place where we can tell who's is whos. I am pretty curious to see storms.

lol i'm sure you are, and i can't wait for you to flame...
sadly though you will have to wait till the voting is over to find out who made what.

so make sure you don't vote because you don't want to look stupid if you pick mine, but i doubt you will because mine isn't very good at all imho, i didn't want many votes in this round.

[xkingx]

Is there a place where we can tell who's is whos. I am pretty curious to see storms.

lol i'm sure you are, and i can't wait for you to flame...
sadly though you will have to wait till the voting is over to find out who made what.

so make sure you don't vote because you don't want to look stupid if you pick mine, but i doubt you will because mine isn't very good at all imho, i didn't want many votes in this round.

aww <3 I love you man. I really do. Your so cute. I wanted to vote a 10 for you.

[zeder]

Entries (pending)

my vote goes to the lovers card with tidus...

to the maker - you've improved by a lot, and i love the outcome. it looks great, i've seen other tarot cards, and even some CTCG made in this style. just a couple small touch-up's and it could pass for professionally made imho.

/e oh so that's how the voting is, i'll edit later

Storm, if you're in the GGT you can't vote!

We Can't?