Sorry Mary, but to me this seems like an effort to try and sneak the "tkp going to the player, not the guild" idea in via the backdoor, and I am pretty sure the cows will see it the same way. Not that I disagree with that idea, but I do with this.
hi kit
my suggestion is to "match the GXP shown on the Guild Advisor to the GXP on guild page"
please code it that the "GXP seen in the Guild Advisor" = "current GXP on guild page" !!!
you seem to be talking about those "1-man-guilds" / small guilds which have been Titan Hunting for YEARS, this is nothing new & if you check out most players guild size who are against my idea you will notice that they are either "1-man-guilds" / small guilds who would have to put more "effort" due to more Player activity / competition !!!
again, I am not suggesting something "new" (that players are able to leave their guild in order to Titan Hunt which was impossible before due to game mechanics, its already possible, my suggestion just enables a lot more players to be able to do the SAME too => increase Player activity => more competition => good for the game in general since more players can participate in the Titan Event
what for instance, should stop me from jumping outta the guild, clear the bounties on guild member, only to join again? (I'd love to do that, mind you )
again, ALL I am suggesting is this:
please code it that the "GXP seen in the Guild Advisor" = "current GXP on guild page" !!!
you can already do this NOW, in this "current system" so my suggestion did NOT create it at all, its already there !!!
infact PvPers have reported this (incl. me a few times years ago but nothing done so far, BigGrim can verify this)
How about players who left a guild before this takes place would that info still be there?
That would be interesting to see.
I will tell you how the Guild Advisor has been working since it was implemented (this has NOTHING to do with my suggestion)
I will take your character as an EXAMPLE because you were in my guild before:
you are NOT in my guild anymore so when I look at the Guild Advisor I obviously do not see anything related to you !!!
you are currently in the guild "Problem 6" & when you look at your Guild Advisor you will see the same amount of GXP (69 bil) as shown at your guild page (69 bil) !!!
NOW let's assume you return to your previous guild:
the amount of GXP on your guild page would be ZERO BUT your Guild Advisor would show the amount of GXP you had BEFORE you left !!!
hope that answers your question & again, what I explained to you had ZERO to do with my suggestion, I only explained how the Guild Advisor works regarding GXP !!!
please feel free to ask if you have any more questions
answer this
I leave my guild to hunt seasons titans, after the event ends I get back to my guild
after coming back is my gxp the same before I left my guild?
well you already answered your question in your next posts yourself BUT here we go ....
with my suggestion YES, your GXP you worked for years on (FSPs / donations / .......) will not be lost since my suggestion is to automatically tie / match the GXP shown in the Guild Advisor to the GXP shown on the guild page !!!
if you are not in your guild (where you hunted & earned the GXP) then obviously your guild will get ZERO GXP !!!
for some players more player competition is a bad thing and are against marys idea
how can more player competition be a bad thing?
it's a matter of perspective:
for those who do not want to put more effort or any competition then they will obviously not agree with my suggestion
for those who were unable to hunt a single Seasonal Titan during the Titan Event BUT will NOW be able to finally take part in an Event will agree with my suggestion
either way I do not blame them at all & not everyone has the same viewpoint !!!
I understood that she wanted the latter too but where did you read that the gxp stays the same at every guild?
the guild advisor is not the same at every guild
obviously the Guild Advisor is NOT the same at every guild !!!
you get GXP in the guild you hunted in !!!
Edited by mary4ever, 16 July 2017 - 12:05.