It just seems harsh somehow to effectively penalise the top guilds just for being too good.
I really don't see it as penalising them if it is giving us the reason to add more new Titans, giving them many more to hunt. The Titans were not supposed to be monopolized.
I am not a titan hunter (yet) so I am personally not affected by this. But why do you start with restricting the access to titans before you introduce new? Also, you make templates in the auction house (yay!) then you make a new create function without templates. And then leave to implement this restriction on titans instead. Frankly, that is poor planning on your part.
I think many in my guild are titan hunters because here at or near eoc there is really little else to spend you stam on if you don't want to attack other players. As a guild we are rich enough that this is not a question of money but of having good fun.
Virtually yours,
Zennaro