37 replies to this topic

[spyders]

Group 1
B 9/10 ... -1 for tornado

[TreeFrog]

Group 1
B 9/10 ... -1 for tornado

Please take the time to read how the voting works.

[LemmyKilms]

Group 1
A. 6 Disasters are chaotic and I'm just not feeling it. A wave hitting the shore at all points at the same time is too unnatural, it's more like a Hollywood movie, too scripted. The 2 identical box looking things in the upper right of the wave crest are a distraction to me.

B. 9 I like the black and white (sepia might have been better?) because it's like an old time picture, which pairs well with the old house.

Group 2
A. 6 I can't figure out if that is a planet exploding or getting hit by an enormous meteor. The planet is all chard on the outside, but I would think that the flames from an explosion would burst from several locations and wouldn't be as large as is shown. If it's being hit by a meteor of the size that the flames suggest, I think that the body of the meteor would be seen. I do like the fissures on that planet, it reminds me of a volcano.

B. 5 Although the flames and creek look realistic, I would think that there would be trees in the background ablaze and the flames in the brush much higher (I've seen too many brush and forest fires here in Cali.). Some embers raining down would have been a nice touch. The upper left is rather void of anything, perhaps the text could have been placed there?

Group 3

A. 4 A volcano erupting I believe would have a crater at least if the top weren't being blown off. And the surface looks much too smooth. The explosion is much too fine, as I read earlier, like fireworks. The flames encircling everything is a bit too much of a distraction.

B. 6 The face is a nice concept but wasn't successful, especially the lack of emotion. The tornado is too rough along it's edges. If you were using the road meeting the tornado as a metaphor as the path of destruction, I applaud you for that.

(I claim little knowledge as to the making of an avatar, so please forgive me for the lack of comments pertaining to the creation process. I only know what I like. I hope.)

[Wesleysdf]

(I claim little knowledge as to the making of an avatar, so please forgive me for the lack of comments pertaining to the creation process. I only know what I like. I hope.)

No worries, thanks for the input mate

[Kara]

Group 1

A: 7/10 - the wave is nice but the city is unclear:/

B: 10/10 - love it everything fits so well

Group 2

A: 6/10 - looks nice but feels like more could be made

B: 6/10 - looks nice but just not my taste

group 3

A: 7/10 - well made

B: 5/10 - the face dosen't fit with the rest of the picture IMO

[aa0007]

(I claim little knowledge as to the making of an avatar, so please forgive me for the lack of comments pertaining to the creation process. I only know what I like. I hope.)

No worries, thanks for the income mate

You mean input? .

[Kayesha]

Group 1
A - 78
B - 91

Group 2
A - 75
B - 80

Group 3
A - 69
B - 64

[aa0007]

Bump. I think this needs some advertising.

[Wesleysdf]

Group 1
A: Pretty cool but the colour scheme/blending is bugging me
8.5/10
B: Blending is good but B&W kinda takes away the fierce feels of a tornado
8.2/10

Group 2:
A: Placement, Too much gray on colour scheme, Smudged smudged but it looks unfinished
7.1/10
B: Nice idea, background is pretty cool, horrible render choice. Seems like the animal inst givin a s*** to whats going on Maybe a diferent one expressing some concert about the flames aroud would be better
7.6/10

Group 3:
A: pretty good, just not feeling the colour scheme. Too much white and undersaturated. Maybe a stronger/darker red/orange would be better
7.8/10
B: If the render choice was bad on 2b, this one probably ruins it. The face doesnt belong there, plus I dont see an angry face or even mother nature.
5/10


If you have any complaints please go yell at aa0007, thanks.

[aa0007]

I wanna see EVERY ARTIST IN FS responding to this thread . So going by everyone that's made a thread on the graphics forum recently ..

ghetoghost
senira
sustortias
peterownz
hbklives
darkdyablo
neil7887
kaliwyn
chagryn
subject1
mycurse
haloartist
clearxwing
kaboooom
roan
dragon1314
impurity
flucht
patnov
mini100
sahardy
athdenald

and others .

Some of you might have voted already, I'm too lazy to check. The rest of you,get voting .

[ghetoghost]

He's to lazy to check whose posted but has enough energy to find all the names of artists

[aa0007]

He's to lazy to check whose posted but has enough energy to find all the names of artists

Yup. I just had to open the graphics forum to see the recent posters, eliminating is extra work .

[zeder]

Group 1
A - 7 Feels like a poster for the SyFy channel
B - 10 What no cow?

Group 2
A - 6 Some stars in the background behind the text would have made it better
B - 9 Maybe the deer on fire?

Group 3
A - 8 Not sure what to say, just doesn't feel right
B - 10 What no cow?

[mimdala]

Group 1
A, 9/10: Really great, the only thing that bugs me is that the water looks like it's coming out of nowhere. Other than that, it's beaut
B, 8/10: I don't really like the black and white, but the cloud and rain effects are great

Group 2
A, 8/10: Really cool, just think that "planetary disaster" should be depicted on a larger scale, with even more destruction, lol!
B, 10/10: This one is my favorite. Scary and beautiful at the same time.

Group 3
A, 9/10: Awesome! I feel like it could have some more dark parts around the edges to increase the dramatic impact.
B, 8/10: I like this, the mother nature thing is a neat idea

[Kayesha]

Group 1
A - 102.5
B - 117.2

Group 2
A - 96.1
B - 106.6

Group 3
A - 93.8
B - 87

[TreeFrog]

This has ended. Names are posted and I'll get the theme up for the next round soon. Congrats to those moving on.

[Roan]

Group 3, the weak group lol!

Good job to others! Was fun competing!

[Sahardy]

As always, I love you all!
Don't hate me afterwards. <3