50 replies to this topic

[ghetoghost]

Am i allowed to redo my points? I thought i had to give 15 to each group

[Patnov]

Here are my votes...

 

Group 1

A ) 8 Love it, the light is great and respect the theme...

B ) 5 The idea is good, but...

 

Group 2

 

A ) 5 The little girl look angry... O.o And to bright for me...

B ) 6 Like it, there is work in this one

 

Group 3

 

A ) 5 I don't get very well the theme in this one, and another angry little girl...

B ) 8 I love the idea that the kid imagines a castle in a Junkyard... It needs a little bit of more work...

 

Group 4

 

A ) 8 Very good with the theme...

B ) 5 Another sad little girl...

 

Group 5

 

A ) 6 For the idea, i don't give more cause is a little bit blurry...

B ) 3 I don't see the child imagination... I like the sig, but, where is the theme here...

[WarQueen]

Am i allowed to redo my points? I thought i had to give 15 to each group

 

so long as there is no decreasing 1 to increase another, I have to problem with you revoting.
Only ones who should not revote are those who voted AFTER I fixed the typo.

[WarQueen]

idk what to do about G1 voting now.
do I add 1B ) to another group? :S

[beanopoly]

idk what to do about G1 voting now.
do I add 1B ) to another group? :S

Maybe next round, you should not pair up the entries. I think you have people vote up to 10 points and they can give a more realistic voting. But just my suggesting.

[Hic242]

idk what to do about G1 voting now.
do I add 1B ) to another group? :S

 

Isn't the system based on Top overall, not winner in each group, now?

If that's the case then it shouldn't matter.

[ghetoghost]

so long as there is no decreasing 1 to increase another, I have to problem with you revoting.
Only ones who should not revote are those who voted AFTER I fixed the typo.

I'll just keep my points then, some are a lil' higher than i wanted but eh

 

idk what to do about G1 voting now.
do I add 1B ) to another group? :S

Keep it, it will still be based on 1-10 scale so it won't change someones vote on it that much

[Hic242]

G1

A. 9 - Best of the bunch for sure! I am not sure why the artist requested for it to be taken down, this is great!

B. 5 - Not bad but not as creative as some of the others.

 

G2

A. 7 - Nice but could use a bit more 'imagination'

B. 6 - Interesting but a lot of blue, some other bright colors would be nice.

 

G3

A. 6 - Interesting but there's not much of a background and that child looks too evil

B. 7 - One of my favorites of this round. 

 

G4

A. 8 - Fits into the theme extremely well. It's great! One of my favorites!

B. 5 - Doesn't really make me think of a child's imagination. Just makes me think of a child's ukulele

 

G5.

A. 3 - Doesn't look like a lot of work was put into this :/

B. 7 - I like the artwork a lot and I see how it could fit into the theme of 'imagination' but I don't see the connection to children, sorry :/

[Roan]

Isn't the system based on Top overall, not winner in each group, now?

If that's the case then it shouldn't matter.

Actually if it works like I think all group winners pass to next round. Then for the others left, the 2 with less points are eliminated.

[Wiivja]

 

Group 1

 

A ) 10 Love it

 

B ) 5 Not bad

 

 

GROUP 2

 

A ) 7

 

B ) 7 Both are good

 

GROUP 3

 

A ) 8 This is great I would be interrested in buying this one.

 

B ) 6

 

 

GROUP 4

 

A ) 10 The best one I think

 

B ) 4

 

 

GROUP 5

 

A ) 1

 

B ) 3 Good but doesnt fit the doesnt really get me to think of a childs imagination

 

 

[YouNoSeeMe]

G1

 

A - 8 I like this one the best eventhough it was removed.

B - 6

 

G2

 

A - 7 I feel they are both equally good pieces so its a draw

B - 7

 

G3

 

A - 6

B - 8 I like the idea behind this one more. 

 

G4

 

A - 8  Both pieces were nice but liked this one a tad bit more.

B - 7

 

G5

 

A - 3

B - 10 I do feel this show a childs imagination very well.  I feel its unique from the rest because it doesnt have a child put in the piece but rather the text and the topaz makes it feel kid like if you can understand my thinking. lol

[kimbo]

Here are my respective votes :

 

Group 1:

 

A-  9 >>This one looks awesome (Perfect for the theme)

B-  6 >>Good workmanship as well, nice.

 

 

Group 2:

 

A- 7.5

B- 7.5 >> For me it's a Draw, this two looks good but not really that much.

 

Group 3:

 

 A-5   >> Nicely done but am not really convinced,something is lacking for me, sorry:((

 B-10 >> First time i see it, there's an outright connection to my eyes, amazing

 

Group 4:

 

A-6  >> For me this is just a vry simple artwork, sorry

B-9  >> This one somehow, again bring some essense to the theme and also i like the color combo.

 

Group 5:

 

A-5 >>

B-5 >>  It's a deadlock for me, somehow there was effort in creating this but could not really perk up my interest, Sorry

Edited by kimbo, 13 November 2013 - 16:16.

[Elokin]

G1

A     0/10     entry removed

B     7/10     It looks neat, like the ghost is drifting into the child's mind

 

G2

A     6/10     I like the idea of seeing something "more" out the window

B     8/10     This one is pretty cool. I just wish the robot half of the child continued through one whole side of the body.

 

G3

A     4/10     This one looks good, but I'm not sure how it fits the theme

B     10/10    I really like this. It fits the theme well and looks good too.

 

G4

A     9/10     I really like this.

B     6/10     I like this, but the imagination aspect didn't really come through for me.

 

G5

A     5/10    It fits the theme, but it seems too plain to me.

B     6/10    This one looks cool, but I don't really understand how it fits the theme.

[bulseye71]

group 1...B...its the only one to vote on (10pts)

group 2...B...I like the composition  better than the other one (10 pts)

group 3...A...I like the "flow" better than the other one...(10 pts)

group 4...A... I like the theme" reading feeds the imaginiation"(10 pts)

group 5...B...Just better graphics, rather than the "photo" used in the other one (10 pts)

Edited by bulseye71, 13 November 2013 - 23:51.

[ghetoghost]

group 1...B...its the only one to vote on (10pts)

group 2...B...I like the composition  better than the other one (10 pts)

group 3...A...I like the "flow" better than the other one...(10 pts)

group 4...A... I like the theme" reading feeds the imaginiation"(10 pts)

group 5...B...Just better graphics, rather than the "photo" used in the other one (10 pts)

You must vote on both pieces for your vote to count. 

[WarQueen]

voting is over. I will tally things up in the morning and will post the next theme. Cheers to all the participants!

[LLLovely]

I would prefer to rank them all in order in which I like them. The pairing is not fare to some since I prefer some pairs to all the others. I think if you rank each from which you like best to least you would get a fare vote.

[WarQueen]

since we had 1 drop out, only 1 person will be eliminated by score in this round.

 

Lowest score was G5-A

 

Thank you for participating and we hope you will join us again in the next GGT.

[WarQueen]

The 3 voters who will recieve a free avatar are:

 

Roan
Wiivja
ghetoghost

 

 

Also, here's the theme for Round 3

http://forums.hunted...showtopic=59302

[Patnov]

As I put it in my Bio and on the shout box, I'm although giving a free avi to 3 voters, the winners are... dmr, Elokin and Wiivja. Please contact me to place your order...