I'm not actively playing, so I'll say it, my opinion doesn't count and I can truly say how the Season PvP system evolved, I was fine with it.
What I did not understand with the poll was why not separate the PvP and Bounty system, as some folks had issues with just the BB - or at least that was what I was seeing.
Also I have to agree with Cyrus on the point he makes on page 2 about the 547 "Don't Mind" votes. Don't mind is, by my interpretation: 'doesn't bother me, I'm not doing it, have at it'.
I know it takes time, but perhaps refining the poll and breaking down components would be valueable? Perhaps don't have Yes - No votes, maybe have "N/A", and a scale of how much people like or dislike each component. I know you're not scraping the whole concept Hoof, but you're only bringing it back for short stints here and there.
Scale: 1 = Worst thing ever; 2 = not my cup of tea; 3 = meh, I may play, I may not; 4 = Cool but I'd like some tweaks; 5 = YeeHaw Love It!
Just a thought. I just felt the poll was a bit too simplistic.