- Found the Fallen Sword
- Got the flawless Calgorn skin
- Got impression from sword
- Went to Buccaneer Griffith with impression
- Went to Temple of flame and acquired the 15 servant trinkets
- Turned them into Buccaneer Griffith and was to receive charm
Did not receive a charm. Quest (gold button COMPLETE) says I received a "powerful new charm" but was never presented the popup for the charm, and never received it in my inventory (in any bag). Received nothing but the Raiders of the Lost Tombs reputation (and a bit of coin).