I agree Penny. so the solution would be to make a 3rd column to reevaluate Top ranked guilds rather than taking anything away from guilds.
However, this should apply to all top ranked lists then. So if you have a rich guild that has no active players within 30 days, then they should be excluded from the current richest guilds. Have a 2nd column for historical richest guilds. Same for titan hunting, if that guild has no active players within 30 days, then they should be excluded from the current top titan guilds. Have a 2nd column for historical top titan guilds. However, if that guild were to get 1 active player within 30 days, then they would reenter the current top titan guilds or current richest guilds based on their respective ranking.
This is a fair amount of coding for the cows so its up to them if they want to bother with it. I certainly do not think this would be high priority but if enough people want it, why not?
I like Ryebred's idea in terms of updates to gvg overall and having a top ranked list for a few months and then having a reset between sessions. Each session would conclude with a tournament that guilds qualified for to gain entry. I would refer you back to Ryebred's thread on gvg for specifics (I obviously paraphrased / oversimplified his ideas).
Edited by Windbattle, 24 February 2019 - 19:04.