Jump to content

Guild Modifications Needed


  • Please log in to reply
59 replies to this topic

Poll: good idea / bad idea? (37 member(s) have cast votes)

good idea / bad idea?

  1. Great idea Hoof please implement ASAP (47 votes [59.49%])

    Percentage of vote: 59.49%

  2. needs some work but good idea (14 votes [17.72%])

    Percentage of vote: 17.72%

  3. i dont agree with everything (6 votes [7.59%])

    Percentage of vote: 7.59%

  4. i hate everyone (1 votes [1.27%])

    Percentage of vote: 1.27%

  5. i hate Boris (4 votes [5.06%])

    Percentage of vote: 5.06%

  6. i am seeking medical attention (7 votes [8.86%])

    Percentage of vote: 8.86%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 20:06

1. top 3-5 lines in chat for important messages only founder or someone with permission can post in (these lines dont scroll down and are for messages of leaders to their troops)

2. Date last logged on. Visible in guild manage screen only. (so we can see inactives)(visible by sertain ranks only/ranking option)

3. total gold donated / and total fsps donated visible in guild manage screen only.(visible by sertain ranks only/ranking option)

4. Rank Management ability should not allow you to raise someone above your current rank within the guild.

5. Rank Creation - you should not be able to create a rank that has abilities you do not have or to be above rank that you have.

6. Bank withdrawal privileges should be up to 1000/10000/100000/1000000/10000000 /24 hours so a disgruntled member wont destroy the entire guild but can have money for repair and emergencies thereby encouraging donations to the guild bank.

7. ppl with kick ability cannot kick anyone above their rank

8. Blocking of a slot in a guildstorage a) a block on storing anything in the spot without right rank permission (handy for that last slot to be always open for group hunts B) not being able to take the item without certain permisiion (great to avoid someone who is new to take off with the guildstorage items ) c) both ways no storage / no withdrawal without permission ( to protect guilds most valuble posessions )

9. Mass Message option to entire guild and sertain rank

10. Guild Group kick option or minnimum lvl option (this is to create groups within your level and to keep people who are much lower from joining, this is more so important with the new relic system) also limiting the ammmount of people that join cause sometime you only need 2 or 3.

11. If guildfounder is gone for more then 30 days there should be a way to vote in new guildfounder or perhaps the next highest rank takes over. (the reason for this is some of the guilds exeptionally large and if guildfounder disapeares or gets banned by gamedevelopers all the investments into the guild disapear)

12. Reverse the order of guildstorage so that the last open spot fills up first that way the top page will always show whether or not there is any space left in guildstorage (will resollve lots of prblems)

thats all for now please get these changes so its easier for big guilds to manage themselves.

#2 fs_baine

fs_baine
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 20:17

I agree with most of these points.

Comment on 4 -- level shouldnt make a difference in ranking people.
I think what you meant to say is not be able to rank someone higher than your current rank, thus preventing possible abuse.

Comment on 6 -- We dont have this problem with guild bank due to only 1 person can withdrawl funds, and there is nothing you can do against a disgruntled guild founder :lol:
However I think it'd be a great idea for other guilds that get ripped off

#3 fs_davidjames

fs_davidjames
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 20:36

a comment on number 3:
only a guild founder or someone with the appropriate permissions should be able to see how much gold/fsp someone has deposited. there is no reason for a low ranking member of a guild to know this information and the same can probably be said for number 2 also.

as for number 6:
i just don't see it as necessary because only the highest of ranks should be able to withdraw from the bank anyway.

otherwise i would definately like to see the first 5 suggestions implemented.

#4 fs_taven

fs_taven
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 20:40

4-6 shouldnt be available to anyone except founders and cofounder either way
but i do like #1, 2, but 3 i like DJ a little better

#5 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 20:42

[

quote="Baine"]I agree with most of these points.

Comment on 4 -- level shouldnt make a difference in ranking people.
I think what you meant to say is not be able to rank someone higher than your current rank, thus preventing possible abuse.


That is exactly what i meant thanks for correcting

Comment on 6 -- We dont have this problem with guild bank due to only 1 person can withdrawl funds, and there is nothing you can do against a disgruntled guild founder :lol:
However I think it'd be a great idea for other guilds that get ripped off


this is so a guildfounder can allow sertain ppl to withdraw partial guildfunds to buy fsps ect or manage funds to allies and other members when guildfounder is not around

#6 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 20:51

4-6 shouldnt be available to anyone except founders and cofounder either way
but i do like #1, 2, but 3 i like DJ a little better


i disagree not every guildfounder can be online all the time this will allow creation of officers who are incharge when guildfounder not around but cannot takeover a guild/ destroy it ect and ruin the game for all members of the guild

like officers who accept and rank new members kickout rif ruff ect.

edited and added #7

#7 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:00

a comment on number 3:
only a guild founder or someone with the appropriate permissions should be able to see how much gold/fsp someone has deposited. there is no reason for a low ranking member of a guild to know this information and the same can probably be said for number 2 also.


for me it seems there could be a togle switch for that as ranking option.
knowing what others donate can be a coompetive feature and a guildfounder can give out special ranks to ppl who donate most say : knight of darkstalkers can become exalted knight of darkstalkers if he donated more then 50 fsps to the guild and if he donated 300k + gold he can have lord in front of his rank (would make it more interesting) and guildfounders can create their own system among the guildmembers


as for number 6:
i just don't see it as necessary because only the highest of ranks should be able to withdraw from the bank anyway.


one implementation of this would be to allow mebers to withdraw x ammount of gold for their needs to incourage always depositing into guild bank
one woould not care bout their own personal account for emergencies if he knew he can alway access 10k from guild bank should he need to

#8 fs_davidjames

fs_davidjames
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:09

i guess with us lvling and xp contrib is most important if it can be toggleable(i think i just made a new word)then that would be ok otherwise i want to keep gold/fsp contrib just to the guild leaders

#9 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:11

i guess with us lvling and xp contrib is most important if it can be toggleable(i think i just made a new word)then that would be ok otherwise i want to keep gold/fsp contrib just to the guild leaders


and you would have that option by allowing only sertain ranks to see
at the same time another would want to allow everyone to see and its up to them :)

#10 fs_azrail

fs_azrail
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:13

wow... this is a real good suggestion topic :shock: all ideas that said in some posts but forgotten and some even didn't thought of before.. i like all of them.. i wonder if we all cry out "hoof" at the same time this updates can be done immediately? i also have another suggestion... ability to block certain guild inventory slots from members of the guild. this way i can put a hellforged item in guild store and block it when the need arises i can sent said item to needed place. under every guild store slot there may be a lock sign and ppl with necessary permissions may withdraw them.. well u get the idea. this way i can open the guild store to every member without fear. may need to work on this idea a bit through.. seems like a bit incomplete... mmm let me think a bit on that :)

#11 fs_davidjames

fs_davidjames
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:18

:lol: i just figured out that we were saying the same thing.

viewing gold/fsp contrib is a rank permission

i had thought you meant that everyone could see it always regardless of rank settings but now we are speaking the same language :lol:

#12 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:27

wow... this is a real good suggestion topic :shock: all ideas that said in some posts but forgotten and some even didn't thought of before.. i like all of them.. i wonder if we all cry out "hoof" at the same time this updates can be done immediately? i also have another suggestion... ability to block certain guild inventory slots from members of the guild. this way i can put a hellforged item in guild store and block it when the need arises i can sent said item to needed place. under every guild store slot there may be a lock sign and ppl with necessary permissions may withdraw them.. well u get the idea. this way i can open the guild store to every member without fear. may need to work on this idea a bit through.. seems like a bit incomplete... mmm let me think a bit on that :)


i like the idea put it up on # 8 with personal modifications hope you dont mind :)

also added 9 and 10

#13 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:28

:lol: i just figured out that we were saying the same thing.

viewing gold/fsp contrib is a rank permission

i had thought you meant that everyone could see it always regardless of rank settings but now we are speaking the same language :lol:


2 smart ppl can always find a solution its large groups of dumb ppl that cause problems my friend :)

#14 fs_kiak360

fs_kiak360
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:30

I agree with most of these points.

Comment on 4 -- level shouldnt make a difference in ranking people.
I think what you meant to say is not be able to rank someone higher than your current rank, thus preventing possible abuse.

Comment on 6 -- We dont have this problem with guild bank due to only 1 person can withdrawl funds, and there is nothing you can do against a disgruntled guild founder :lol:
However I think it'd be a great idea for other guilds that get ripped off

yea i agree
sounds good

#15 fs_azrail

fs_azrail
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 21:57

hey that is good Boris... the idea is much improved now :) i don't mind at all.. i hope to see this suggestions implemented soon ^_^

#16 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 09 February 2007 - 22:10

hey could a moderator sticky this please to see what ppl think

#17 fs_azrail

fs_azrail
  • Guests

Posted 10 February 2007 - 09:43

bump... calling for a sticky.. i think this one is important for the game. i'd rather have one topic for guild improvement topic and able to see all ideas in first post then have hundreds of posts scattered around..

#18 fs_borisdrago

fs_borisdrago
  • Guests

Posted 11 February 2007 - 00:24

bump

#19 fs_valenza

fs_valenza
  • Guests

Posted 11 February 2007 - 01:05

The iades are great. Especially the one with last visit and doantion form each members - the lowest rank would see more who invest time/fsp/golds in the guild and why some have receive higher rank (we can see the deposit on the log, but they left quickly from the log. In our guild, more a player invest inthe guild, more he have acces to a higher rank, with more privileges that he can do.

#20 Thoran

Thoran

    Veteran

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 728 posts
  • Badge
  • Spain

Posted 11 February 2007 - 13:14

a comment on number 3:
only a guild founder or someone with the appropriate permissions should be able to see how much gold/fsp someone has deposited. there is no reason for a low ranking member of a guild to know this information and the same can probably be said for number 2 also.

as for number 6:
i just don't see it as necessary because only the highest of ranks should be able to withdraw from the bank anyway.

otherwise i would definately like to see the first 5 suggestions implemented.

-----------
I agree with all, but including DavidJames's changes of #3 and #6.
Good point!

*Sticky* this please

HDBus.gif

I'm also known as @UnoWild

For Fracks Sake, Forum



0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

Font:
Arial | Calibri | Lucida Console | Verdana
 
Font Size:
9px | 10px | 11px | 12px | 10pt | 12pt
 
Color: