There is apparently alot of people who use the FS Helper but there is one other suggestion to add to the helper if at all possible. Its already possible to change member ranks just by going to a members profile, but when you want to change their rank, there isnt the option to kick them. Perhaps this could be added to the profile page for people with the correct permissions? Anyone that uses the helper that thinks this would be a good benefit are welcome to post here and even if you dont have the helper, comments are welcome as well. Guild Founders would really benefit from this feature. Even if they dont use the helper, there should be an option to kick a player from the guild just by going to their profile. Bad or good comments are welcome. Lets see what others think of this.
Fallen Sword Helper suggestion
Started by
fs_torankusu
, May 20 2009 03:19
4 replies to this topic
#1
fs_torankusu
Posted 20 May 2009 - 03:19
#2
Posted 20 May 2009 - 03:21
If I understand you correctly, you are suggesting a "quick kick" option for guild officers?
I think this is a bad idea - kicking somebody should NOT be easy. As a former guild founder (who helped his guild achieve over 200 levels and donated 1000's of FSPs), kicking is seldom done and only in the most serious of offenses (in most cases, anyways).... it shouldn't be any easier or convenient then it already is.
I think this is a bad idea - kicking somebody should NOT be easy. As a former guild founder (who helped his guild achieve over 200 levels and donated 1000's of FSPs), kicking is seldom done and only in the most serious of offenses (in most cases, anyways).... it shouldn't be any easier or convenient then it already is.
#3
fs_torankusu
Posted 20 May 2009 - 03:24
it was just an idea to make it easier to kick inactive players or guild thieves. thanks for replying though. it just to me seems a hassle to check their activity level, go back to the guild mainpage, go to the ranks area and then kick them from there. it just would make it easier to do it on their profile...and I do mean for that to be an option for guild founders and co-founders only.
#4
Posted 20 May 2009 - 03:28
What would really help your overall concept is making it so that the guild advisor summarized longer periods of time (1 week, 1 month, etc.) and maybe more activity (guild items taken, guild items placed in store, items tagged, items untagged), etc....
I used to keep those stats for my old guild in a MYSQL database, ugh! I got it down to about 3 minutes of work per night, but really... HCS should just program that data query theirselves, lol.
I'm still opposed to any kind of a quick option - if you have to kick people that often, you've got a bigger problem on your hands. To build a good guild, you need a strong nucleus of players who get along well and share the same general views on gameplay (in terms of rules, etc.)..... add a simple google docs application and poof, you've got a decent way to control who comes in your guild and you'll have to kick less. (hopefully!)
I used to keep those stats for my old guild in a MYSQL database, ugh! I got it down to about 3 minutes of work per night, but really... HCS should just program that data query theirselves, lol.
I'm still opposed to any kind of a quick option - if you have to kick people that often, you've got a bigger problem on your hands. To build a good guild, you need a strong nucleus of players who get along well and share the same general views on gameplay (in terms of rules, etc.)..... add a simple google docs application and poof, you've got a decent way to control who comes in your guild and you'll have to kick less. (hopefully!)
#5
fs_torankusu
Posted 20 May 2009 - 03:42
that would indeed help. right now my main problem is all the newbie players who come on maybe 2 or 3 times a week, dont donate gold or xp, and just take up space, then go inactive for long periods of time. the idea you had though would be a good one, to enhance the guild advisor. it would be better to see which items are recalled most frequently and who uses them most frequently. if it kept track of that, we would know which sets to have more than 1 of. that would help greatly in the long run. this would work out for anyone, not just ones with the FS Helper.
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users

