Jump to content

Photo

PVP Idea


  • Please log in to reply
240 replies to this topic

Poll: Would you agree with this as a better pvp system (63 member(s) have cast votes)

Would you agree with this as a better pvp system

  1. Voted Yes (35 votes [54.69%])

    Percentage of vote: 54.69%

  2. Voted No (14 votes [21.88%])

    Percentage of vote: 21.88%

  3. Voted Needs more work (15 votes [23.44%])

    Percentage of vote: 23.44%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#41 fs_balmaina

fs_balmaina
  • Guests

Posted 10 September 2010 - 23:24

I like the idea leos .. My style of gameplay is that I enjoy to level.. makes me feel good each week to edge up the board.. I also enjoy PvP .. by playing the arena and GvG.. mainly because it is at no risk to my experience level..and that I have a choice to be involved in it.. getting randomly attacked .. takes away my choices.... gold does not concern me.. so if I was to get hit for gold.. so what ! I will just go get some more next time I hunt.. I mentioned in a previous thread that it would be nice to be able to retailate once.. if someone muggs you.. without the fear of maybe being sent to the bounty board for a maxium de level!

We all know that there is a number of well organised PvP guilds out there who will just punish you if you try and defend yourself or say stuff that they dont agree with.. even the new system of the PvP board is being exploited by groups and guilds of people.. so that unless you are in one of those guilds or have a previous "arrangement"..then .. you have little or no chance of finishing in the top 30 .. I see it every week.. with some "unknown" in the top 10 of the PvP board .. and then bang.. he is not even in the top 50 anymore.. because there has been a cordinated and pre planned.. attack on him.. So in reality.. there is just about no chance for 99% of the game population to have access to the new sets and equipment.. unless they are prepared to pay through the nose for it.. from the very people who are attacking you.. is this good for the game..? I think not!

#42 fs_coyotik

fs_coyotik
  • Guests

Posted 10 September 2010 - 23:41

I like the idea leos .. My style of gameplay is that I enjoy to level.. makes me feel good each week to edge up the board.. I also enjoy PvP .. by playing the arena and GvG.. mainly because it is at no risk to my experience level..and that I have a choice to be involved in it.. getting randomly attacked .. takes away my choices....


Sadly, this is what many PvPers are refusing to accept. Many claim that "PvP" is not "player versus player", but THEIR favorite flavor of it, "player versus a sitting duck that, when hit, has the option to a) fight back (which they have little interest in probably) B) increase their loss by paying for retribution c) do nothing".

Claims like "opt out would kill PvP" actually prove how badly PvP sucks in the game and how the PvPers know it. What prevents them from fighting each other and enjoying PvP against the best? They NEED the levellers to have their fun (whereas the levellers don't need PvPers at all to have their fun). This is a big imbalance. Why cannot I enjoy the game I like (levelling) and at the same time spoil their fun? If they're able to take my gold and XP, I want to be able to take their ability to attack or make them gain no gold in combat - in other words, I want to be able to hit them where it will hurt them - WHILE doing something I like and risking something I don't really care about very much. Yes, it's taking it to the extreme, of course, but without taking it to the extreme, many people refuse to understand why opt-out is so much in demand (and why even a partial opt-out that protects your XP only would be appreciated by many).

#43 fs_nthnclls

fs_nthnclls
  • Guests

Posted 10 September 2010 - 23:48

The point, for many, isn't really opting out of PvP, it's opting out of the completely indefensible XP loss. Frankly, I'd be for the opt out system even if it meant I lost double gold and lost the ability to bounty gold hits.


I like this idea better for purely selfish reasons lol.

And Kibora, please stop tainted the threads you post in with agonizing levels of idiocy.

#44 fs_cheechong

fs_cheechong
  • Guests

Posted 10 September 2010 - 23:50

other than not being able to bounty gold hits I love this idea. if someone were to hit me for a few million I'd like to be able to bounty them.....simple as that. everything else is perfect tho.(I'd opt in just for the fun of it not much of a pvp player)

#45 fs_kibora

fs_kibora
  • Guests

Posted 10 September 2010 - 23:50

wow, no need for harsh words. All this can be settled in a calm...orderly...BAZOOKA!!!! *pulls out my bazooka*

#46 fs_fsmage01

fs_fsmage01
  • Guests

Posted 10 September 2010 - 23:53

I like the idea leos

#47 moonfrost

moonfrost

    Veteran

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 528 posts

Posted 10 September 2010 - 23:59

I like the idea leos .. My style of gameplay is that I enjoy to level.. makes me feel good each week to edge up the board.. I also enjoy PvP .. by playing the arena and GvG.. mainly because it is at no risk to my experience level..and that I have a choice to be involved in it.. getting randomly attacked .. takes away my choices....


Sadly, this is what many PvPers are refusing to accept. Many claim that "PvP" is not "player versus player", but THEIR favorite flavor of it, "player versus a sitting duck that, when hit, has the option to a) fight back (which they have little interest in probably) B) increase their loss by paying for retribution c) do nothing".

Claims like "opt out would kill PvP" actually prove how badly PvP sucks in the game and how the PvPers know it. What prevents them from fighting each other and enjoying PvP against the best? They NEED the levellers to have their fun (whereas the levellers don't need PvPers at all to have their fun). This is a big imbalance. Why cannot I enjoy the game I like (levelling) and at the same time spoil their fun? If they're able to take my gold and XP, I want to be able to take their ability to attack or make them gain no gold in combat - in other words, I want to be able to hit them where it will hurt them - WHILE doing something I like and risking something I don't really care about very much. Yes, it's taking it to the extreme, of course, but without taking it to the extreme, many people refuse to understand why opt-out is so much in demand (and why even a partial opt-out that protects your XP only would be appreciated by many).


you're such a contradiction of ideas at any given time its just pathetic...one day you're trying to change this and the next day you're off on another chenge that was the opposite of whatever the first idea was...in how you word things sometimes i wonder if you dont go to a restaurant, order a bowl of chicken noodle soup and then return it demanding your money backX10 if one of the noodles happens to stretch over the side of your spoon or not be the same size as the rest in the bowl

pvp is a part of this game whether you choose to engage in it or not..its not a difficult task to "opt out" of it if you make the proper changes to your gameplay style...ie:gold onhand, making anti-pvp comments, the fact that your guild founder has the threat of taking 5 from anyone who attacks as well as that it was in your guild history for the longest time(btw, i just never found anyone over there with any gold in my range or i'd have tested it)

#48 fs_andypearce

fs_andypearce
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:08

I'm undecided about this, while PvP is a part of this game, be it a small part, I'm still not sure you should be able to opt-out of it, I like that if it did happen people could still be hit though.

It would stop the unnecessary bullying of players though...I like that part.

#49 fs_coyotik

fs_coyotik
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:16

you're such a contradiction of ideas at any given time its just pathetic...one day you're trying to change this and the next day you're off on another chenge that was the opposite of whatever the first idea was...


I'm not trying to change anything today :). I'm simply trying to show how badly is PvP designed here, because all the time I keep hearing from a few people the same story about how this is a PvP game and how PvP is essential and whatnot.

pvp is a part of this game whether you choose to engage in it or not..


Yep, it's part of this game. A very misdesigned part, neglected for a long time and full of illogical issues. And that's why I welcome every suggestion that either attempts to fix some of those problems or diminishes their impact. I'm not a fan of total opt-out at all (even though I'm convinced that it would not kill pvp at all), but this idea seems like a feasible compromise, so why not?

making anti-pvp comments


anti-pvp? Or "anti-the-way-the-loud-pvpers-on-the-forum-claim-is-the-one-and-only-pvp"?

the fact that your guild founder has the threat of taking 5 from anyone who attacks


Yea, he stopped playing back before the VL nonsense was introduced... the delevels were of some good use back then :). Another prime example of how HCS "design" the game for PvP... perhaps it's their business model that they changed the system to be more bully friendly, to allow anybody to harass somebody else into buying XP lock.

#50 fs_coyotik

fs_coyotik
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:20

I'm undecided about this, while PvP is a part of this game, be it a small part, I'm still not sure you should be able to opt-out of it, I like that if it did happen people could still be hit though.

It would stop the unnecessary bullying of players though...I like that part.


I don't think that opting out from XP-loss only would be a big loss for the game. No issues with getting hit for gold at all, I think that most people accept this and have learned to take measures. I've been attacked for gold just once in the last year, becoming a contributor to StangValle's cake... and if a guildmate gets hit for gold, I usually ask them "how much did you have" followed by "and why did you have so much"?

#51 fs_nthnclls

fs_nthnclls
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:22

I really, really like the idea of not being able to bounty when you opt out of xp loss, it creates an interesting trade-off...but I may be biased, lol.

#52 fs_balmaina

fs_balmaina
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:23

I like the idea leos .. My style of gameplay is that I enjoy to level.. makes me feel good each week to edge up the board.. I also enjoy PvP .. by playing the arena and GvG.. mainly because it is at no risk to my experience level..and that I have a choice to be involved in it.. getting randomly attacked .. takes away my choices....


Sadly, this is what many PvPers are refusing to accept. Many claim that "PvP" is not "player versus player", but THEIR favorite flavor of it, "player versus a sitting duck that, when hit, has the option to a) fight back (which they have little interest in probably) B) increase their loss by paying for retribution c) do nothing".

Claims like "opt out would kill PvP" actually prove how badly PvP sucks in the game and how the PvPers know it. What prevents them from fighting each other and enjoying PvP against the best? They NEED the levellers to have their fun (whereas the levellers don't need PvPers at all to have their fun). This is a big imbalance. Why cannot I enjoy the game I like (levelling) and at the same time spoil their fun? If they're able to take my gold and XP, I want to be able to take their ability to attack or make them gain no gold in combat - in other words, I want to be able to hit them where it will hurt them - WHILE doing something I like and risking something I don't really care about very much. Yes, it's taking it to the extreme, of course, but without taking it to the extreme, many people refuse to understand why opt-out is so much in demand (and why even a partial opt-out that protects your XP only would be appreciated by many).


"opt out" of it if you make the proper changes to your gameplay style...ie:gold onhand, making anti-pvp comments


lol.. have you bumped you head .. prior to writing that...? .. "making anti pvp comments" .. this is an open forum.. open for discussion of a subject .. not an oppotunity to threaten or intimidate people because their opinion is not the same as yours.. everyone is entilted to their opinion..

I dont like PvP in it's present form !! there I said it.. does that mean now that a mob is going to come hunting for me with pitchforks and burning brands ?.. the whole point of this thread was to somehow work out a way to make it a bit fairer for both sides .. PvP'ers and Levellers.. I dont want to see PvP stopped in the game.. I firmly believe that it has it's place.. but if I make a consious decision not to play that part of the game.. then it should be respected and the developers of the game should ensure that it is also protected.. I am a paying customer as well.. and should have a few rights about how I wish to play the game within it's parameters.. and I should not have to feel that I am being forced into a part of the game that holds no interest to me!

#53 moonfrost

moonfrost

    Veteran

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 528 posts

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:26

I'm undecided about this, while PvP is a part of this game, be it a small part, I'm still not sure you should be able to opt-out of it, I like that if it did happen people could still be hit though.

It would stop the unnecessary bullying of players though...I like that part.


I don't think that opting out from XP-loss only would be a big loss for the game. No issues with getting hit for gold at all, I think that most people accept this and have learned to take measures. I've been attacked for gold just once in the last year, becoming a contributor to StangValle's cake... and if a guildmate gets hit for gold, I usually ask them "how much did you have" followed by "and why did you have so much"?


then at least you're reasonable and can understand the logistics of why people generally get attacked..obviously this doesnt cover all the reasons but this is a good portion of it...xp loss is a driving factor in pvp though, i know that i use it as a bargaining tool when i hit people

btw, you seemed to have glossed over the chicken soup thing, is it true then?


lol.. have you bumped you head .. prior to writing that...? .. "making anti pvp comments" .. this is an open forum.. open for discussion of a subject .. not an oppotunity to threaten or intimidate people because their opinion is not the same as yours.. everyone is entilted to their opinion..

I dont like PvP in it's present form !! there I said it.. does that mean now that a mob is going to come hunting for me with pitchforks and burning brands ?.. the whole point of this thread was to somehow work out a way to make it a bit fairer for both sides .. PvP'ers and Levellers.. I dont want to see PvP stopped in the game.. I firmly believe that it has it's place.. but if I make a consious decision not to play that part of the game.. then it should be respected and the developers of the game should ensure that it is also protected.. I am a paying customer as well.. and should have a few rights about how I wish to play the game within it's parameters.. and I should not have to feel that I am being forced into a part of the game that holds no interest to me!


who was making threats? the initial part was how to opt-out of pvp...and we both know making comments like that is what attracts players to keep an eye on you and watch..how many players have been hit for threats in their bios? and trust me, i'd never choose to use a burning brand to come after you, i might melt

#54 fs_robotussin

fs_robotussin
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:30

DOUBLE the gold loss for opt outs and increase xp gain while hunting for opt ins and you get my vote.

#55 fs_nthnclls

fs_nthnclls
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:30

lol.. have you bumped you head .. prior to writing that...? .. "making anti pvp comments" .. this is an open forum.. open for discussion of a subject .. not an oppotunity to threaten or intimidate people because their opinion is not the same as yours.. everyone is entilted to their opinion..

I dont like PvP in it's present form !! there I said it.. does that mean now that a mob is going to come hunting for me with pitchforks and burning brands ?.. the whole point of this thread was to somehow work out a way to make it a bit fairer for both sides .. PvP'ers and Levellers.. I dont want to see PvP stopped in the game.. I firmly believe that it has it's place.. but if I make a consious decision not to play that part of the game.. then it should be respected and the developers of the game should ensure that it is also protected.. I am a paying customer as well.. and should have a few rights about how I wish to play the game within it's parameters.. and I should not have to feel that I am being forced into a part of the game that holds no interest to me!


There is a huge difference between saying that you don't like pvp, or presenting a solution to a problem, real or perceived, that's well thought out, like leos's is, and coming on the forum and ranting like a certain player recently did when they said:

I know I'm not alone in being unamused by the brats running around unsupervised and attacking unsuspecting players. Really, what's the point? To prove you can act like a thug?

If we could opt out of open PvP activity, it would free the player not interested in interrupting their game to change gear, deposit gold and place bounties to get on with just playing the game how they'd like.
If you want to have the brats run up behind you and mug you then by all means, Opt in.


It's posts like that that practically beg for 100 stam, not posts that simply say they "dislike" pvp.

#56 fs_andypearce

fs_andypearce
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:32

I'm undecided about this, while PvP is a part of this game, be it a small part, I'm still not sure you should be able to opt-out of it, I like that if it did happen people could still be hit though.

It would stop the unnecessary bullying of players though...I like that part.


I don't think that opting out from XP-loss only would be a big loss for the game. No issues with getting hit for gold at all, I think that most people accept this and have learned to take measures. I've been attacked for gold just once in the last year, becoming a contributor to StangValle's cake... and if a guildmate gets hit for gold, I usually ask them "how much did you have" followed by "and why did you have so much"?


It wouldn't be a loss at all really, seeing as most PvPers hit for gold, and the other ones who hit for XP are usually bullyers, so that's no loss :P

#57 fs_andypearce

fs_andypearce
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:33

DOUBLE the gold loss for opt outs and increase xp gain while hunting for opt ins and you get my vote.


Funny enough I thought about doubling gold loss myself, not sure how it would work though

#58 fs_robotussin

fs_robotussin
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:35

I'm pretty sure it would work just like it does now, except gold loss/gain would be 2 times normal :)

#59 fs_andypearce

fs_andypearce
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:40

I'm pretty sure it would work just like it does now, except gold loss/gain would be 2 times normal :)


Yeah I know, I was thinking that it would bring more gold into the game for some reason, think I need more sleep

#60 fs_robotussin

fs_robotussin
  • Guests

Posted 11 September 2010 - 00:41

:)

I've been there, Andy.



Its only fair that some incentive/penalty be implemented if there is even a discussion of an opt out.


0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

Font:
Arial | Calibri | Lucida Console | Verdana
 
Font Size:
9px | 10px | 11px | 12px | 10pt | 12pt
 
Color: