Is there an option that says you hate any type of PvP protection? Seems like neither of these options are acceptable to me.
I think that the answer is this: When you are PvPing you should be forced to choose an option.
Attack for?
Gold
PvP
XP
You can pick ONLY one option and the other items CAN'T be lost. So gold thieves steal ONLY gold not XP or PvP points. PvP Farmers steal ONLY PvP points and not gold or XP. And when revenge is needed, XP is taken and nothing else.
Gold thieves don't WANT to take your gold AND XP. They want the gold (and would actually like you to keep your XP). The FS Police Departments (I call "Sherriff" first) want your XP. It is how we keep bio's semi-civil and some order in a game of internet tough guys.
This poll is a extrememly biased. It's like asking which way you'd prefer to die and not giving an "I'd like to live option".
Maxwell
I personally Really like MD's idea as I am a lover not a fighter...oops I mean levelerSarcastic or not, I'll respond.
This way, you can pay for awhile of protection and be able to level well enough. We can keep the Xp lock too *shrugs*
I was not trying to be sarcastic but sadly inflection and facial feature are only available to a limited amount when typing

